Warrior in Two Worlds

Quanah with his wives To-pay and Cho-ny circa 1892
Photo by WESTERN HISTORY COLLECTIONS/OU

---

As a way of life was ending on the American frontier and another emerging, one of the state’s most storied citizens made a paradigm-shattering passage from king of the plains to leader of the Comanches. How did a young man of mixed blood, orphaned in childhood, become one of the most influential Native Americans in history? Meet Quanah Parker, the warrior-chief who changed the West forever.

By JIM LOGAN
May/June 2011

On the back lot of an old amusement park, behind an Indian trading post in Cache, Oklahoma, is a structure author S.C. Gwynne, in his best-selling and critically acclaimed 2010 biography Empire of the Summer Moon calls “one of the great, obscure treasures of the American West.” 

Built in the late 1800s, the old residence once housed guests that included Geronimo, cattlemen Charles Goodnight and Burk Burnett, and President Theodore Roosevelt. It belonged to a man many consider one of the greatest figures in American history, Comanche warrior-statesman Quanah Parker. 

The son of a white-captive mother and a Comanche chief, he was one of the most feared fighters of his day. With his people, he endured the devastating transition from freedom on the open plains to paradise lost to engulfment in a culture vastly removed in time and tradition. A controversial, caring leader who attained remarkable success and influence in a nation still aglow with manifest destiny, he remains one of the few to transcend that upheaval. 

To appreciate Quanah Parker the legend, one must first know his people. The Comanches were among the greatest warrior-horsemen who ever lived. Brutal, wild, and magnificent, they commanded an empire that spanned 240,000 square miles across today’s Kansas, Oklahoma, Texas, eastern New Mexico, Colorado, and into Mexico. 

Their formidability in warfare was the reason Spain’s northern advance from Mexico halted where it did and why France’s westward movement from Louisiana was turned back. No tribe had as much influence on America’s own westward march. The Texas Rangers and the Colt six-shot revolver resulted directly from the Comanche threat. Of the tribe’s several bands, the fiercest and most isolated were the Quahadi, to whom Quanah belonged. 

In 1836, Parker’s Fort in Texas (approximately ninety miles south of today’s Dallas) was attacked by a Comanche-Kiowa war party. Five whites were killed and five taken captive, including nine-year-old Cynthia Ann Parker. 

The Comanches grew to love their young captive (calling her Nautdah, whose name has been interpreted to mean “someone found”), and she eventually became the wife of Peta Nocona, the chief whose band led the Parker’s Fort attack. Sometime around 1850, in a flowered meadow along Elk Creek below the Wichita Mountains, she gave birth to the first of three children. She named him Kwihnai, which means eagle. His nickname became Quanah, possibly a result of a mispronunciation of his birth name. 

Approximately a decade later, in 1860, Cynthia Ann Parker’s Comanche camp on the Pease River west of present-day Vernon, Texas, was attacked by soldiers and Texas Rangers. Twelve-year-old Quanah and his younger brother, called “Peanuts,” escaped. The others were killed, except for three captives, Cynthia Ann Parker and her infant daughter Prairie Flower among them. 

Whether Chief Nocona was killed that day, or if, as Quanah would later assert, perhaps for reasons of family honor, he was not present are matters still being debated. In any case, he was never again seen by his family. 

When her captors noted her blue eyes and light skin, they soon realized she was the long-sought Cynthia Ann Parker, famously reported to have been seen with the Comanches. 

In the wake of the sensation her recapture created, she would never recover from being twice torn from one culture into another. She rejected the white ways of her relatives in wooded east Texas and attempted many times to escape back to the plains and people she loved. When Prairie Flower died of pneumonia at age five, four years after her capture, her grief was intense. Six years later, at age forty-three, Cynthia Ann died. 

Peanuts died of unknown causes, and Quanah’s own boyhood as a part-white orphan was difficult. This changed as he reached warrior age in his midteens, when he took on a striking appearance—gray-eyed, unusually muscular, with high cheekbones and an imposing six-foot frame. He was forthright, fearless, and intelligent. 

His band ranged primarily over a broad area across western Texas and Oklahoma, with its epicenter on the southern high plains of the Texas panhandle.

| 2 | 3 | Next Page